Antoine-Aimé Dorion, no to Confederation, 1865

Antoine Aime Dorion Confederation in the 1860s, saying that the French would be swamped by English-speakers
Antoine Aime Dorion was opposed to Confederation

Dorion led the Parti Rouge (Liberals) in the 1850s and he had served with George Brown in a short-lived government. Early in 1865 representatives from the United Province of Canada (today’s Quebec and Ontario) met to decide if they would proceed with a federation that had been negotiated to include the English colonies in Atlantic Canada. Dorion was opposed to this wider confederation, as were a majority of the francophone delegates. They feared that the English majority would overwhelm the French. Dorion also opposed the idea of a legislative union, in which the central government held most of the power. His arguments in 1865 illustrate the historic disagreement over the founding reality of Canada. Was confederation to be the union of two nations, or was it a federation of equal provinces? These conflicting views still exist.

“The French will be completely overwhelmed by the majority of British representatives” Continue reading Antoine-Aimé Dorion, no to Confederation, 1865

John A. Macdonald, yes to Confederation, 1865

John A Macdonald's speech in 1865 promoting confederation
John A Macdonald’s speech promoted Confederation

In 1864, the colonies of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, and Newfoundland planned to meet in Charlottetown to investigate a union among the British Maritime colonies. John A Macdonald and other representatives from Upper and Lower Canada invited themselves to the meeting and arrived by steamship. They proposed a wider union which would include Upper and Lower Canada.  The group met again in Quebec City in October 1864 and agreed to proceed. Then in February 1865, the legislature of Upper and Lower Canada met to decide whether to ratify the proposal. Macdonald’s was the first of many speeches in the long debate in Quebec City.

“If we wish to be a great people … this can only be obtained by a union of some kind” Continue reading John A. Macdonald, yes to Confederation, 1865